The State of Marketing
THE INCITE MARKETING REPORT 2017
Personalization, Content, Storytelling and Attribution as the
Core Competencies of the Marketing Department of the future
incite-group.com
2
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Introduction
Welcome to Incite Group’s second State of Marketing Report. This
comprehensive white paper is based on original research. It provides
keen current market insights and importantly, it also compares shifts in the
market as well as in priorities from last year’s report.
The research highlights these changes as well as identifies new trends
and areas of interest. These benchmarks will be useful in sizing up your
strategies with those of your peers around the globe.
Incite Group recognizes that different users have different use cases and so
we separate the corporate end-user marketers from the broader marketing
community.
The international survey features respondents from every geographical
region and across industry sectors including agencies, B2B & B2C marketers,
and digital social media.
The report focuses on three major areas that are key to marketing success:
content and story-telling, marketing attribution, and personalization. These
three topics remain the most important priorities for leaders in this field.
In fact, these three major themes are spotlighted, with each featuring an
independent conference track, at the upcoming Incite Marketing Summit.
It will be held in New York on October 24 and 25.
The summit focuses on essential changes needed to market effectively,
engaging customers who are tired of marketing. The agenda is built around
the priorities of in-house marketers and features more than 60 senior
executives from household name brands (American Express, Chobani,
Denny’s, Hiscox, GE).
3
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Methodology
The report is based solely on responses to a wide-ranging survey conducted
from February through mid-April of this year. There were nearly 1,400
respondents to the survey, a 23% increase from last year, with very high
participation levels completing the entire survey.
The survey was sent exclusively to the Incite Group’s readership, with no
attempts to focus on specific job titles or geographies (though given our
primary focus on marketing and customer experience, it’s not surprising
that these functions made strong showings among respondents).
The majority of the questions were closed and the available answers were
produced by the research with in-house marketing professionals conducted
by the Incite Group year-round. Some open-ended questions were asked,
though the only responses used in the white paper are those regarding an
individual’s job title.
Throughout the survey we separated out the ‘in-house’ marketers from the
rest of the marketing community. The respondents chose their classification
through self-selection from their answers to the question “What type of
company do you work for?” Those answering “corporate/end user” defined
themselves by choosing that answer.
Opportunity to learn more
At the Incite Marketing Summit (NYC, 24-25 October), speakers from the world’s biggest and most
successful brands will be sharing their insight – and skin-in-the-game experience – on how to leverage
the unique benefits of personalization, attribution and content marketing. You can join them!
Click here to find out more
4
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Who responded?
The Incite Group survey was conducted over a two-month period with 1,372 professionals taking part.
They came from a variety of companies, industries, and locations from around the globe.

Most Popular Respondent Job Titles
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
50%
60%
Marketing
Digital
Communications
Content
Business Development
Social Media
Customer
Other
Given the nature of the survey and Incite Group’s target audience, it was not surprising that more than a
quarter of respondents were marketers—far more than the next several groups combined.
The next most popular job titles were digital, communications, content, and business development,
respectively.
There was a common theme among all respondents as the lion’s share function to create and provide
exceptional customer experiences.
In subsequent sections of this white paper we break out corporate responses from the rest of the
marketing community. This is done to highlight differences in approach and in opinion between in-house
marketers and those in the broader marketing community. This highlights where there are parallels and
distinct departures.
You can see where each group stands on the issues and consider whether the in-house side has moved
too slowly to adopt new trends or technologies or perhaps just deliberately enough where results have
5
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
not been proven. After all, the rest of the marketing community is trying to sell the in-house marketer on
something and it will be their job to persuade in-house counterparts to make moves in mobile marketing
with demonstrable results.
Most Popular Respondent Seniority
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
50%
Director
Manager
Vice
Executive / Analyst / Associate
CMO
Chief (Non-CMO)
Other

As for corporate hierarchy, the respondents ranged from veterans in the C-suite to junior associates just
cutting their teeth.
While there were a number of CEOs and other senior executives, managers and directors again
dominated the self-identified seniority levels. Those two categories combined to account for four out of
ten respondents.
Geography
For the second straight year, respondents hailed from all around the world.
Marketing specialists from the USA and Canada led the way, followed by
mainland Europe, the UK, with Asia just behind.
Respondent Industry
Given Incite Group’s large reach to a global, diverse audience of marketers,
the survey respondents were again from a variety of industries.
6
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
But before we drill down into sectors, we asked respondents to broadly categorize their company.
The Corporate/Brand designation topped the charts with Agency/Service Provider a close second.
Together they accounted for 70% of respondents with MarTech firms third at 10%.
There wasn’t much change in terms of which industry groups they hailed from, with the lion’s share
representing Incite Group’s core audience: the end user marketer that works for a large corporate brand.
The biggest constituency came from the agency/service providers at 17%, unchanged from last year, and
marketing tech firms again came third biggest group at 10%. Digital/social media/mobile jumped one
spot to second place with 11%.

5%
10%
15%
20%
0%
Most Popular Respondent Industry
Agency
17%
Digital/Social/Mobile
11%
B-to-B/Corporate
10%
Marketing
Hi-Tech Industry
9%
Education
6%
Financial Service
5%
Telecommunications
5%
Retail/eCommerce
5%
Healthcare
3%
FMCG
2%
Fundraising/Non-Profit 1%
Opportunity to learn more
At the Incite Marketing Summit (NYC, 24-25 October), speakers from the world’s biggest and most
successful brands will be sharing their insight – and skin-in-the-game experience – on how to leverage
the unique benefits of personalization, attribution and content marketing. You can join them!
Click here to find out more
7
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
The best-represented industry, as one may expect, was technology. It was followed by education, retail/
eCommerce, and financial services tied with telecomm.
We asked respondents to self-select the type of company they worked for and whether they are an ‘end
user,’ ‘in-house’ corporation or brand; an agency or service provider; a marketing technology firm; or
something else.
As we continue our analysis, in many instances we break out the corporate responses from the rest of the
marketing community. We do this to identify divergences in opinion as well as ideas where the groups
are in lockstep. This may present some enterprising marketers with inspiration and ideas for campaigns
to bridge the gaps. But it may also offer instructive opportunities to hit pause and reconsider whether
some trends and ideas are effective in marketing to the corporate sector.
The most pressing issues in marketing right now
Brands can identify and communicate with loyal and so-called “super users” on mobile more easily
than ever. But the upshot is those same consumers can and do readily drop brands and quickly cut off
direct communications (by deleting apps or unsubscribing from emails) if there are problems with mobile
communications and/or there are disappointing experiences.
The most successful brands are tapping into this unprecedented amount of data about their customers
and creating custom content and marketing to cater to the power user and often create evangelizing
opportunities as well.
And marketers tell Incite Group that the most pressing issues have changed a little bit in the past year
since we conducted the first survey. One major change is the amount of topics that were high vote
getters.
Check out the results below for greater insight.
Eight different categories received votes of at least 40% or more of all marketer respondents, classifying
them as “essential” for this year and beyond. Part of that was structural as a couple of categories were
split to get more detailed interest in personalization and content marketing. By comparison, just one
issue received 40% of votes a year ago.
8
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east

Which Issues are Essential in 2017
0%
20%
60%
10%
30%
40%
50%
Personalization:
Understanding Customers &
Defining A Single...
Brand Storytelling
Building Immersive
Customer Experiences
Personalization: Unique
Experiences
Social Media For Customer
Engagement
Content Marketing:
Distribution
Content Marketing:
Production
Sales Enablement:
New Marketing / Sales
Relationship
Internet Of Things For
Deeper Customer Insight
Marketing Attribution
Total essential
Corporate essential
MarTech essential
Artificial Intelligence To
Power Personalization
Virtual Reality & Augmented
Reality
9
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
That topic--Content marketing--was the clear leader a year ago and it remains a major focus, but this
year we broke that out into two distinct areas: production and distribution. Perhaps the narrower focus
kept it out of the top five topics. Instead, Personalization: understanding customers and defining a single
customer view led the way with nearly half of respondents citing it as the biggest issue for 2017.
Brand storytelling made a big jump, up some six percentage points, to the second biggest issue from
fourth place a year ago. The focus was particularly stark among MarTech firms, with 52% of these
respondents citing it as crucial. That was the highest reading of any issue with either MarTech or Corporate
respondents.
A newcomer to the survey—Building Immersive Customer Experiences—finished with a strong third-
place showing, garnering votes from 46% of all marketers.
The biggest overall leap was for Social Media for Customer Engagement, which is clearly becoming table
stakes for many brands. It rang up a 43% reading as essential this year, jumping from below 30% in 2016.
And MarTech execs said it was an even higher priority, with a 47% vote tally.
It’s not a huge surprise that immersive brand stories told via social media would attract votes. Clearly
there is even greater emphasis on controlling the message and targeting specific consumers with creative
content rather than simply sending ads or offers.
The biggest slide in the past year is Sales Enablement: the new marketing/sales relationship dropped a
full 10 percentage points this year from 2016. It still registered a 40% reading, but as more companies,
especially in the B2B industry, have removed silos and encouraged greater collaboration between the
marketing and sales teams, it may simply not be considered as an essential issue for 2017 since the
integration is already in place. In fact, some marketing executives have said as much to Incite Group
reporters and on stage at the group’s conferences.
Still it clearly remains an issue for corporate marketers, 44% of them cited it as a major issue. That’s
the third highest total among corporate issues and a full 10 percentage points higher than the MarTech
reading.
Interestingly, the Internet of Things for Deeper Customer Insight led some other new categories with 24%
giving it the nod, while Artificial Intelligence to Power Personalization and Virtual Reality and Augmented
Reality brought up the rear. That indicates that many marketers don’t see AI, VR/AR as viable near-
term channels but given the emphasis on immersive customer experiences and storytelling, these are
categories to keep an eye on.
Least Important Issues
In fact, these three categories were deemed the least important issues this year. VR/AR received an
overwhelming 40% of all respondents saying “Not Important” and that includes a whopping 45% of in-
house marketers vs. just 31% in MarTech. Meanwhile AI was the next least important issue, pulling 27%
overall. IoT wasn’t quite as negative at 17%, but that total is still less than its “essential” votes.
10
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east

Which Issues are Unimportant in 2017
0%
20%
50%
10%
30%
40%
Unimportant Issues All
Unimportant Issues Corporate
Unimportant Issues MarTech
Personalization:
Understanding Customers
Brand Storytelling
Building Immersive
Customer Experiences
Personalization: Providing
Unique Experiences
Social Media For Customer
Engagement
Content Marketing:
Distribution
Content Marketing:
Production
Sales Enablement:
New Marketing / Sales
Relationship
Internet Of Things For
Deeper Customer Insight
Marketing Attribution
Artificial Intelligence To
Power Personalization
Virtual Reality & Augmented
Reality
incite-group.com/east
Real Engagement in
the Age of Personalization
Cut through the noise with seamless, consistent and impactful interactions
that truly impress your customer and build relationships
A CONFERENCE DESIGNED EXCLUSIVELY FOR THE IN-HOUSE MARKETER
Learn: 3 in-depth
conferences, 60+ major brands
speaking, 4 themes, 17 exclusive
case studies, and an agenda built
by the marketing community
Network: 400+ peers in
attendance, 70%+ working in-house
at major brands. In short - useful,
targeted networking you won’t get
anywhere else
Collaborate: Establish
relationships with key marketing
executives at the biggest brands
active in the USA today
#incitesummit
incite-group.com/east
Peter McGuinness
Chobani
Chief Marketing and Brand Officer
Jerome Hiquet
Tough Mudder Inc
Chief Marketing Officer
Russell Findlay
Hiscox
Chief Marketing Officer
Emily Culp
Keds
Chief Marketing Officer
John Dillon
Denny’s Corporation
Chief Marketing Officer
12
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
What Matters Most
For 2017, Incite Group expanded the scope for the most important, broader themes, which we will
expand upon in the rest of this report. We asked everyone to let us know what the most pressing issue
will be for them in 2017. One thing is clear, the laser focus on better identifying, tracking, and using data
to convert consumers is top of the charts.
More than a third of corporate respondents selected “understanding customers -and their journey -
better”. In fact, the issue racked up about the same amount of votes as the next two topics combined:
the move Towards One-to-One Marketing and Content Marketing: Scale Production and Effective
Distribution. Brand Storytelling was a close fourth while Marketing Attribution and Understanding the
Interplay Between Channels and Platforms brought up the rear.
It is interesting to note that Content Marketing dominated the corporate responses in 2016 with 44%
of the votes for Most Important Issue of the Year. It garnered just about 18% this year. Understanding
Customers was not one of the response options a year ago but clearly is weighing the most on the minds
of in-house marketers.

Which Issue is Most Important in 2017?
Understanding customers -
and their journey - better
36%
Towards one-to-one marketing
and unique customer
experiences
19%
Content Marketing: Scale
production and effective
distribution
18%
Brand Storytelling: Craft an
authentic story that resonates 17%
Marketing Attribution & understanding
interplay between channels
and platforms
9%
Other
1%
Corporate respondents only

Opportunity to learn more
At the Incite Marketing Summit (NYC, 24-25 October), speakers from the world’s biggest and most
successful brands will be sharing their insight – and skin-in-the-game experience – on how to leverage
the unique benefits of personalization, attribution and content marketing. You can join them!
Click here to find out more
13
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Content Marketing
What Is Your Budget for Content Marketing in 2017?
What is your Content Marketing budget in 2017?
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
50%
60%
Les
s than

$1
00
,00
0
$1
00
,00
0 –

$2
50
,00
0
$2
50
,00
0
– $
1m
Ov
er
$1
m
Ot
he
r
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only

When examining content marketing budgets for corporate respondents,
it becomes apparent that the amount of money earmarked this year
trails 2016’s set-asides. The only increase for 2017 is for budgets below
$100,000, higher budgets decreased across the board while the number of
budgets north of $1 million was little changed.
14
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Budgets for Content Marketing
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
50%
Les
s than

pri
or
yea
rSam
e a
s
pri
or
yea
r
Up
to
20
%
mo
re
tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
20
%
to
50
%
mo
re
tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
50
%
to
10
0%
m
ore

tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
Ov
er
10
0%
m
ore

tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only

Examining the budgetary plans more closely, you can see this trend illustrated in the chart above. Not
only are fewer marketers spending big on content marketing, underscored by far fewer firms doubling
their budgets, but many of them are not even spending as much this year as in 2016.
The number of in-house marketers spending less than the prior year jumped seven percentage points to
17% in 2017.
The sky’s not falling, however, as the lion’s share of firms plan to spend the same as the prior year. That
group represented 40% of votes, unchanged from 2016’s reading. And the number of respondents seeing
a year-over-year increase between 20% and 50% as well as those forecasting bumps of 50% to 100% over
the year ago period both rose in this year’s survey from 2016’s.
Opportunity to learn more
At the Incite Marketing Summit (NYC, 24-25 October), speakers from the world’s biggest and most
successful brands will be sharing their insight – and skin-in-the-game experience – on how to leverage
the unique benefits of personalization, attribution and content marketing. You can join them!
Click here to find out more
15
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
At face value it appears the total number of dollars from these two different groups of respondents is
expected to be lower in 2017 than last year, with fewer bigger bets, but toes and even ankles are getting
into the water with more medium-sized increases over last year. Marketers should also keep in mind that
these are forecasts, we know that what people say in surveys, polls and even budgetary meetings are
different from what they do.
Perhaps skepticism remains on the validity of content marketing? Or chieftains are not yet convinced by
the ability to quantify its effects.

How is your ROI for Content Marketing?
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
50%
60%
Perfectly
Well
To an extent
Not well
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
There were signs of improvements in the ability to measure the ROI of content marketing in this year’s
survey versus 2016. The number of those who answered “well” to this question of measurement surged
by more than half again as much to a reading of 31%, while those saying “perfectly’ tripled off of a
marginal base to 3% this year. Perhaps this increase is responsible for fewer people this year selecting
the non-endorsement response “to an extent.” The naysayers weren’t much moved, however, with the
“not well category” still above one-quarter of respondents.

16
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
10%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
0%
How important are these issues?
Consistency of brand story across...
Defining your brand story
Content for brand awareness
Content for lead generation
New media formats: video, mobile...
Effective distribution and getting...
Scaling content production
Measuring the success of content...
Corporate respondents only

Is your leadership convinced of Content Marketing’s value?
30%
20%
10%
0%
40%
Absolutely
Largely
To an extent
No
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
17
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
But notice leadership, among respondents, is taking notice and endorsing the tactical use of content
marketing. There was a marked increase in this year’s survey from 2016 for those who “Absolutely”
are convinced of the value, apparently stealing some voters from the “Largely” and milquetoast “To an
Extent” answers. Plus there were fewer responses with flat-out “No’s.”
Content Is Still King
While assigning a value on the effectiveness of content marketing is clearly an issue, there’s little doubt
that the content itself, remains of paramount importance.
The most essential issue in Content Marketing, as cited by more than half of in-house respondents, is
“Effective Distribution and Getting Content in the Right Places.”
That is closely followed by “Content for Brand Awareness.” The next two issues go hand in hand,
“Consistency of Brand Across the Organization” and “Defining Your Brand Story.”
So creating a clearly defined brand identity and connecting content that tells that story directly to the
correct consumer is the current Holy Grail for content marketing.
It’s only after these responses that the issues of creating “Content for Lead Generation” and “Measuring
the Success of Content Marketing” come into play among respondents.

Are you leveraging Content Marketing’s potential?
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
50%
Yes - we’re
leveraging content
marketing’s full
potential
Somewhat - we’re
certainly seeing the
benefit of using
content marketing
To a limited extent
- we see some
benefit from using
content marketing
No - we’re not able
to drive real benefits
from our content
marketing effort
18
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
How are you benefiting from Content Marketing?
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
70%
50%
30%
10%
0%
90%
80%
60%
40%
20%
Financially –
Content Marketing
drives revenue
Engagement – Using
Content Marketing
engages our customers
Brand – Content
Marketing strengthens
our brand
Meanwhile, despite a slight dip in the number of votes, two-thirds of those
surveyed still see the biggest benefit from content marketing is engaging
customers, followed by a strengthening of the brand.
Even as those two groups declined from 2016, the number of corporate
marketers seeing financial rewards from increased revenue was on the rise.
Still at just 27%, it remains a smaller number than many in the industry
would expect. That may also go a long ways towards explaining the
shrinking budgets and fewer bigger bets on content marketing.
The bottom line is clearly whether content marketing can move the revenue
needle and clearly there remains skepticism among decision-makers and
the ability to apply financial metrics creating visibility for clear ROI.
Opportunity to learn more
At the Incite Marketing Summit (NYC, 24-25 October), speakers from the world’s biggest and most
successful brands will be sharing their insight – and skin-in-the-game experience – on how to leverage
the unique benefits of personalization, attribution and content marketing. You can join them!
Click here to find out more
incite-group.com/east
Real Engagement in
the Age of Personalization
Cut through the noise with seamless, consistent and impactful interactions
that truly impress your customer and build relationships
A CONFERENCE DESIGNED EXCLUSIVELY FOR THE IN-HOUSE MARKETER
Learn: 3 in-depth
conferences, 60+ major brands
speaking, 4 themes, 17 exclusive
case studies, and an agenda built
by the marketing community
Network: 400+ peers in
attendance, 70%+ working in-house
at major brands. In short - useful,
targeted networking you won’t get
anywhere else
Collaborate: Establish
relationships with key marketing
executives at the biggest brands
active in the USA today
#incitesummit
incite-group.com/east
Peter McGuinness
Chobani
Chief Marketing and Brand Officer
Jerome Hiquet
Tough Mudder Inc
Chief Marketing Officer
Russell Findlay
Hiscox
Chief Marketing Officer
Emily Culp
Keds
Chief Marketing Officer
John Dillon
Denny’s Corporation
Chief Marketing Officer
Personalization
& Experience
Content &
Storytelling
Attribution
& Insights
Omnichannel
Integration
The revolution in segmentation,
targeting and personalization.
Understand your customer better
to market with more precision
and engage more deeply
Learn to trust your
marketing metrics again -
reliable measurement and
better insights to fail fast
and learn faster
Bridge the gaps and offer
united brand experiences on
all touchpoints of customer
engagement, including social media,
email marketing, mobile, websites,
in-store and digital marketing
How to tell compelling
stories, scale content, and
cut-through the noise with
persona driven messaging
across all channels
October 24 - 25, 2017
Marriott Brooklyn Bridge, New York
5th ANNUAL
MARKETING SUMMIT
2017
THE USA’S BEST BRAND-FOCUSED MARKETING CONFERENCE
SAVE $350! Register before June 16th!
LEARN FROM 45+ BRAND MARKETING LEADERS INCLUDING:
20
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Personalization and the Single Customer View
The importance of personalization and delivering relevant, valuable customer experience remains a
fundamental driver of the content spend we have been discussing.
After all, corporate survey responders indicated that creating content to match a consistent brand
strategy and marketing it effectively to the “right places” is what they most care about.
Yet for all the talk of Personalization, there remains a disconnect when it comes to laying out cash. More
than half of corporate marketers that weighed in for Incite said that they would spend less than $100,000
with more targeted, custom contact and campaigns. That was actually higher than a year ago but in
keeping with other budgetary trends, fewer companies are boosting budgets when it comes to spend
above $100,000. The outlier is the lack of change among those spending north of $1 million.


Budgets for Personalization
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
50%
60%
Les
s t
han

$1
00
,00
0
$1
00
,00
0 –
$2
50
,00
0
$2
50
,00
0
– $
1mOv
er
$1
mOt
he
r
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
21
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Budgetary changes for Personalization Marketing
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Les
s than

pri
or
yea
rSam
e a
s
pri
or
yea
r
Up
to
20
%
mo
re
tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
20
%
to
50
%
mo
re
tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
50
%
to
10
0%
m
ore

tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
Ov
er
10
0%
m
ore

tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
There may be fewer big budgets for increasing personalization, but overall the trend shows faster growth
than in content marketing in this area. Take a look at the graphic and you can see fewer companies
cutting spend on personalization than in 2016, more companies are holding the line on their budgets,
and overall growth including those firms doubling their investment in personalization shows an increase
over the rate of change from 2015 into 2016.
Personalization and single customer view are efforts to fine tune marketing campaigns to more precise
demographic groups but not actually creating individual messages for each customer as well as pulling
data from across departments into one comprehensive, illustrative view of the customer in order to
enable personalization efforts.
It is interesting to note that the ability to gauge the ROI for Personalization remains fairly low in the eyes
of the Incite survey takers. While the number of those saying “Perfectly” ticked up one slightly, there are
still four times as many saying “Not Well”. The bulk of respondents still answered “Well” and “To Some
Extent” but in both cases it was to a lesser extent than in 2016.

22
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Is your leadership convinced of Personalization’s value?
30%
20%
10%
0%
40%
Absolutely
Largely
To an extent
No
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
Nonetheless, nearly two-thirds of corporate marketers who responded indicate their executives see
the value in personalization in slightly bigger numbers than just last year. That’s a pretty high level of
confidence given the low ratings for measuring Personalization’s ROI.
Similarly, marketers say the rewards are not necessarily pecuniary but they do note Personalization is
benefiting their brands through greater engagement and strengthening the brand itself.

Opportunity to learn more
At the Incite Marketing Summit (NYC, 24-25 October), speakers from the world’s biggest and most
successful brands will be sharing their insight – and skin-in-the-game experience – on how to leverage
the unique benefits of personalization, attribution and content marketing. You can join them!
Click here to find out more
23
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Ability to measure ROI of Personalization?
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
50%
Perfectly
Well
To an extent
Not well
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
How are you benefitting from personalization?
Engagement – Using
personalization engages
our customers
72%
Brand – Personalization
engage our customers
47%
Financially – Personalization
drives revenue
35%
Corporate respondents only
These factors all play into the Customer Journey, which marketers are focusing on so closely to try and
boost those financial rewards by better understanding customer behavior on digital platforms. That is
using available data and consumer preferences to surface and deliver more relevant and personalized
experiences that in turn ring up more sales.
24
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Marketing Attribution
“Marketing Attribution” marries analytics with modern marketing skills (Personalization and Content). It
is clearly the most data-centric area featuring Incite Group’s survey and upcoming conference: the Incite
Marketing Conference East. These tactics are currently employed by a smaller group of marketers, but
may be considered the wave of the future. After all, CMOs readily say how marketing is transforming
into a data-led industry and new hires must be able to work seamlessly with data-analysis and traditional
marketing teams.
Marketing Attribution budgets
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
50%
60%
Les
s t
han

$1
00
,00
0
$1
00
,00
0 –

$2
50
,00
0
$2
50
,00
0
– $
1mOv
er
$1
mOt
he
r
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
Almost two-thirds of corporate respondents less than $100,000 in their budgets for Marketing Attribution
as firms are allocating fewer dollars in this direction. The next bucket had a sizeable drop, where just 21%
of respondents have six-figure budgets up to a quarter of a million bucks. That’s down from almost one-
third last year. There was a slight gain for budgets in the $250,000 to one million dollar range.

25
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Marketing Attribution budgetary changes
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Les
s than

pri
or
yea
rSam
e a
s
pri
or
yea
r
Up
to
20
%
mo
re
tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
20
%
to
50
%
mo
re
tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
50
%
to
10
0%
m
ore

tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
Ov
er
10
0%
m
ore

tha
n p
rio
r y
ear
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
Clearly decision makers are taking a wait and see attitude. A growing number, nearly half of corporate
respondents, said their firm’s year-over-year change in spending would be unchanged. But the second biggest
group of survey takers, 15%, said they see a drop in this type of spending compared to 2016’s annual change.
There were no respondents expecting to double their spending or increase it by more than that amount,
while a handful do see large increases of between 50% and 100% (that category had 0 respondents in 2016).
The tide is turning somewhat, albeit slowly, if you look at responses to the question about measuring
ROI. Those measuring it “Well” improved by more than 50% while respondents who say they can track
returns “Perfectly” registered a small 2% but that was a vast improvement over 0 a year ago.
Still it continues to trail the ability to accurately attribute ROI in other major segments, Personalization
(6% said Perfectly) and Content Marketing (3%).
The numbers reporting “Not Well” or “To an Extent” dropped, but still make up nearly half of the survey answerers.
Leadership support appears to remain cautiously optimistic this year compared to 2016 even as the
bosses are not apparently putting greater resources into this area. Interestingly, 32% of answers indicated
leadership was “Absolutely” convinced of marketing attribution’s effectiveness. That was higher than
Personalization (25%) and 10 times Content’s 3% reading. The song remains the same for brand bosses
apparently, as our survey found for the second straight year that they have communicated greater support
for the efficacy of Market Attribution over Personalization and Content Marketing combined.
26
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east


Can you measure ROI of marketing attribution?
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
60%
50%
Perfectly
Well
To an extent
Not well
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
Is your leadership convinced of Marketing Attribution’s value?
30%
20%
10%
0%
50%
40%
Absolutely
Largely
To an extent
No
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
27
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Additionally, there was an uptick across the board in quantifying how
in-house marketers were benefiting from marketing attribution. Those
completing this section told Incite that the biggest change was a change
in engagement, while brand strengthening and financial gains were also
increasing this year versus 2016.


How are you benefiting from Marketing Attribution?
2017
2016
Corporate respondents only
50%
30%
10%
0%
60%
40%
20%
Financially –
Marketing Attribution
drives revenue
Engagement –
Using Marketing
Attribution engages
our customers
Brand –
Marketing Attribution
strengthens our brand
Opportunity to learn more
At the Incite Marketing Summit (NYC, 24-25 October), speakers from the world’s biggest and most
successful brands will be sharing their insight – and skin-in-the-game experience – on how to leverage
the unique benefits of personalization, attribution and content marketing. You can join them!
Click here to find out more
28
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
10%
20%
30%
50%
60%
40%
0%
What’s the most essential issue in Marketing Attribution?
47%
Turning data analysis
into actionable insights
19%
Customer journey
modelling
37%
Testing and optimization
to drive success
26%
Working with IT
to create better
technology...
43%
Reliability of
online metrics
53%
Define ROI of each
channel / platform
40%
Understand the
customer journey in
more depth
Corporate respondents only
Given the overall insights into Market Attribution it’s not a big surprise
that in-house marketers see the most essential issues in this category as
“Defining ROI of each platform,” followed by “Turning Data Insights into
Actionable Information,” and then “Reliability of online metrics.” In other
words tracking the marketing spend and figuring out how to efficiently and
effectively market with the data gleaned through marketing activities.
29
Real Engagement in the Age of Personalization
incite-group.com/east
Conclusion
Marketers in all types of shops: in-house and MarTech remain intensely
focused in their efforts on Personalization, Content Marketing, and
Marketing Attribution.
One divergence to keep an eye on is the apparent voicing of confidence by
leadership in all of these areas but that is not translating into money where
their mouths are, perhaps a sign that they are waiting for more visibility in
ROI as respondents indicated engagement and brand strengthening are
outpacing financial returns or this disparity in spending may presage an
economic slowdown ahead.
Regardless it’s a signal that strategic campaigns may win the day. While
there are clearly differing opinions between different types of shops as
well as executives and marketers as to the extent of investment in each
category, there appears to be unanimity that these major themes and
some slight variations will carry the industry closer to true personalization
with custom content that can be more accurately tracked and quantified
through tighter collaboration between market and data analysis.
Opportunity to learn more
At the Incite Marketing Summit (NYC, 24-25 October), speakers from the world’s biggest and most
successful brands will be sharing their insight – and skin-in-the-game experience – on how to leverage
the unique benefits of personalization, attribution and content marketing. You can join them!
Click here to find out more
incite-group.com/east
Real Engagement in
the Age of Personalization
Cut through the noise with seamless, consistent and impactful interactions
that truly impress your customer and build relationships
A CONFERENCE DESIGNED EXCLUSIVELY FOR THE IN-HOUSE MARKETER
Learn: 3 in-depth
conferences, 60+ major brands
speaking, 4 themes, 17 exclusive
case studies, and an agenda built
by the marketing community
Network: 400+ peers in
attendance, 70%+ working in-house
at major brands. In short - useful,
targeted networking you won’t get
anywhere else
Collaborate: Establish
relationships with key marketing
executives at the biggest brands
active in the USA today
#incitesummit
incite-group.com/east
Peter McGuinness
Chobani
Chief Marketing and Brand Officer
Jerome Hiquet
Tough Mudder Inc
Chief Marketing Officer
Russell Findlay
Hiscox
Chief Marketing Officer
Emily Culp
Keds
Chief Marketing Officer
John Dillon
Denny’s Corporation
Chief Marketing Officer
Personalization
& Experience
Content &
Storytelling
Attribution
& Insights
Omnichannel
Integration
The revolution in segmentation,
targeting and personalization.
Understand your customer better
to market with more precision
and engage more deeply
Learn to trust your
marketing metrics again -
reliable measurement and
better insights to fail fast
and learn faster
Bridge the gaps and offer
united brand experiences on
all touchpoints of customer
engagement, including social media,
email marketing, mobile, websites,
in-store and digital marketing
How to tell compelling
stories, scale content, and
cut-through the noise with
persona driven messaging
across all channels
October 24 - 25, 2017
Marriott Brooklyn Bridge, New York
5th ANNUAL
MARKETING SUMMIT
2017
THE USA’S BEST BRAND-FOCUSED MARKETING CONFERENCE
SAVE $350! Register before June 16th!
LEARN FROM 45+ BRAND MARKETING LEADERS INCLUDING: